Hominid butchers and biting crocodiles in the African Plio–Pleistocene

Hominid butchers and biting crocodiles in the African Plio–Pleistocene

6 Pages · 2017 · 1.28 MB · English

Hominid butchers and biting crocodiles in the African Plio–Pleistocene free download


Hominid butchers and biting crocodiles in the African Plio – Pleistocene Yonatan Sahle a,1, Sireen El Zaatari b, and Tim D White c,d,1 aDeutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG) Center for Advanced Studies: “Words, Bones, Genes, Tools, ”University of Tübingen, 72070 Tübingen, Germany; bPaleoanthropology, Senckenberg Center for Human Evolution and Paleoenvironment, University of Tübingen, 72070 Tübingen, Germany; cHuman Evolution Research Center (HERC), University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720; and dDepartment of Integrative Biology, University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720 Contributed by Tim D White, October 4, 2017 (sent for review September 17, 2017; reviewed by Clark Spencer Larsen and Sileshi Semaw) Zooarchaeologists have long relied on linear traces and pits found on the surfaces of ancient bones to infer ancient hominidbehaviors such as slicing, chopping, and percussive actions during butchery of mammal carcasses However, such claims about Plio – Pleistocene hominids rely mostly on very small assemblages ofbony remains Furthermore, recent experiments on trampling animals and biting crocodiles have shown each to be capable of pro ducing mimics of such marks This equifinality —the creation of similar products by different processes —makes deciphering early archaeological bone assemblages difficult Bone modifications among Ethiopian Plio –Pleistocene hominid and faunal remains at Asa Issie, Maka, Hadar, and Bouri were reassessed in light of thesefindings The results show that crocodiles were important modifiers of these bone assemblages The relative roles of hominids, mammalian carnivores, and crocodiles in the formation of Oldo wan zooarchaeological assemblages will only be accuratelyrevealed by better bounding equifinality Critical analysis withina consiliencebased approach is identified as the pathway forward More experimental studies and increased archaeological fieldwork aimed at generating adequate samples are now required zooarchaeology |Oldowan |taphonomy |cutmarks |equifinality T races on bone surfaces play an important role in document ing humanity ’s everbroadening subsistence base Prominent recent claims of stone tool use at ∼34 million years (Ma) (1, 2), occupation of Eurasia by 26 Ma (3), and hominids in California at ∼130 Ky (4) employ such evidence Experimental and naturalistic investigations in the 1980s led to a claimed dichotomy between Ushaped marks left on bones by “ carnivore ”teeth, and Vshaped traces (cutmarks) inflicted by stone tools (5, 6) Assertions that internal striae and shoulder marks were uniquely associated with cutmarks (7) were aug mented by similar claims for percussion pits and associated striae (8, 9) Today these features are treated as “signature criteria ” (10) and widely thought to accurately diagnose stone tool butchery Oldowan bone and lithic assemblages from Olduvai ( ∼18 Ma) and other excavations have been intensively analyzed for decades and used in considerations of human evolution Indeed, funda mentally different inferences about early hominid carcass pro curement and butchery (eg, hunting vs scavenging) have been derived from such analyses of the very same assemblages (11, 12) Zooarchaeologists have largely followed the orthodoxy that stone tool modifications to bone surfaces are accurately di agnosable from mammalian carnivore damage, and routinely use carnivore to mean mammalian carnivore However, a few zooarchaeologists persistently doubted the proclaimed tool/carnivore dichotomy and cautioned against overreliance on microscopic techniques (13 –15) Lyman consis tently and prophetically cautioned that equifinality could cripple inferences about ancient behavior (16) Early experiments even revealed that animal trampling could mimic cutmarks (17) But with the tool/carnivore dichotomy meme embedded, paleoan thropological attention increasingly focused on subsistence It is now recognized that “linear marks ”and other bone sur face modifications can result from interacting agents that range from people to plants (18) On the basis of the mark(s) alone, it is often difficult to distinguish among the modifying objects (the tooth surface, stone tool edge, or sedimentary particle) and their effectors (the bone chewer, trampling animal, or hominid butcher) Decades of actualistic research have now demonstrated that equifinality cannot be reduced to insignificance with a few more technological advances or experimental studies (19) In deed, rather

------------- Read More -------------

Download hominid-butchers-and-biting-crocodiles-in-the-african-plio-pleistocene.pdf

Hominid butchers and biting crocodiles in the African Plio–Pleistocene related documents

DEPARTMENT of HEALTH and HUMAN - Centers for Disease Control and

507 Pages · 2008 · 6.61 MB · English

influenza, natural disasters, and terrorism, while remaining focused on the threats to health and local, tribal and territorial health network.

A Typology of Victim Characterization in Television Crime Dramas

33 Pages · 2010 · 278 KB · English

her analysis of one season of Law & Order, NYPD Blue, and The Practice. She found that only

Immigration and Economy in the Globalization Process

236 Pages · 2002 · 1.63 MB · English

will need employees with the right skills and motivation. Switching to an active im- Finland by analyzing the development of the volume of foreign-born and foreign na- tionals and direct foreign . In the globalization trend of corporations, competition has shifted from natural re- source and expen

Interpreting sloppy stick figures by graph rectification and

14 Pages · 2001 · 822 KB · English

1 Interpreting sloppy stick figures by graph rectification and constraint-based matching. James V. Mahoney and Markus P. J. Fromherz Xerox Palo Alto Research Center

International Student Guide for Employment in the US

19 Pages · 2012 · 741 KB · English

Problem- If you do not speak English as a native language, you are at a distinct disadvantage communicating with recruiters. Solution- Consciously make an effort to talk with Americans: • Make presentations, take English courses, and work tirelessly at improving your English skills. • Ask a fel

Assistance and Accountability in Externally Managed Schools

37 Pages · 2008 · 263 KB · English

Edison Schools, Inc., is the largest and most visible among a growing number of. Education Management profit EMOs were managing 521 public schools serving nearly 240,000 students across the United . educational services; and management consulting under the “Edison Alliance” flag, through 

22 NAVAJO NATION COUNCIL | Office of the Speaker

2 Pages · 2013 · 295 KB · English

Law and Order Committee receives update regarding and an additional amount of $1.4 million to ensure operation through operations through the winter season.

The European Car Parking Sector Sees M&A Flurry, But Will It Be An Easy Ride For Investors?

11 Pages · 2017 · 813 KB · English

The European Car Parking Sector Sees M&A Flurry, But Will It Be An Easy Ride For Investors? spglobal.com/ratingsdirect. Dec. 6, 2017. 2. Despite lots of M&A activity in the. European car parking sector, the future is somewhat uncertain. Acquisitions are the major growth catalyst for operators, but

An integrated approach to product design and process selection

48 Pages · 2011 · 2.15 MB ·

Narayan Raman .. M? < Bs% .. a geometric series given by TEMP(y) = r * TEMP(

constraints facing the implementation of the greater new orleans urban water plan

5 Pages · 2015 · 480 KB · English

IMPLEMENTATION OF THE GREATER. NEW ORLEANS URBAN WATER PLAN. Annabel Visschedijk en Frans van de Ven*. On September 6th of last year the Greater New Orleans Urban Water Plan. (UWP) was presented. A comprehensive plan which addresses flooding caused by heavy rainfall and